Find the Duplicate Number (Floyd's Cycle)
Given an array of $n+1$ integers where each integer is between 1 and $n$ (inclusive), find the single duplicate number using $O(1)$ extra space.
Why Interviewers Ask This
Interviewers at LinkedIn ask this to assess your ability to recognize non-obvious mathematical patterns in data structures. They specifically evaluate whether you can map array indices to a linked list cycle, demonstrating deep algorithmic thinking beyond standard sorting or hashing solutions. This tests your mastery of space-time trade-offs under strict O(1) memory constraints.
How to Answer This Question
Structure your response using the 'Pattern Recognition and Constraint Mapping' framework. First, explicitly acknowledge the constraints: O(1) space forbids hash sets, and O(n log n) time forbids sorting. Second, visualize the problem by treating the array as a functional graph where index i points to value nums[i], creating a directed cycle due to the duplicate number. Third, explain Floyd's Tortoise and Hare algorithm as two pointers moving at different speeds to detect this cycle. Fourth, detail the two-phase process: first finding the intersection point inside the cycle, then resetting one pointer to the start to find the entry point which is the duplicate. Finally, analyze the complexity to prove both time and space requirements are met, showing you understand why this specific approach is optimal for large-scale data systems like those at LinkedIn.
Key Points to Cover
- Explicitly mapping array indices to a linked list structure to reveal the hidden cycle
- Acknowledging why standard hashing or sorting violates the O(1) space constraint
- Correctly distinguishing between the cycle detection phase and the entry point calculation phase
- Proving the mathematical validity that the intersection of the second phase equals the duplicate value
- Demonstrating awareness of LinkedIn's focus on scalable, memory-efficient algorithms
Sample Answer
To solve this efficiently within O(1) space, I treat the input array not just as a list, but as a linked list where each index points to the next node via its value. Since there are n+1 numbers between 1 and n, at least…
Common Mistakes to Avoid
- Attempting to use a HashSet or frequency array, which immediately fails the O(1) space requirement
- Sorting the array first, which increases time complexity to O(n log n) and modifies the input
- Stopping after detecting the cycle without performing the second phase to locate the actual duplicate value
- Failing to explain the mathematical logic behind why the two pointers meet at the duplicate in the second phase
Sound confident on this question in 5 minutes
Answer once and get a 30-second AI critique of your structure, content, and delivery. First attempt is free — no signup needed.